Many aspiring language learners turn to apps like Duolingo, drawn in by the promise of gamified education and the allure of quick progress. As someone who once enthusiastically dived into learning Mandarin Chinese with Duolingo, I understand the appeal. Like many beginners, I was searching for that magic tool to unlock fluency in this fascinating language.
My journey with Mandarin began with scattered elementary classes, leaving me eager for a supplementary resource. A friend, further along in their Mandarin studies, recommended a free app for vocabulary and sentence structure. Simultaneously, online searches about how long it takes to learn Chinese led me to claims that Duolingo Mandarin users progress as fast as university students. Intrigued, I downloaded the app and was quickly drawn into its engaging system.
My Summer with Duolingo Mandarin: An Addictive Game
For those unfamiliar, Duolingo transforms language learning into an addictive game. Courses are structured by topic, starting with basic introductions and advancing to themes like business and travel. Each course introduces topic-specific vocabulary and short sentences. To progress, you must complete various challenges, such as sentence construction and translation between Chinese and English, aiming to unlock an entire “tree” of courses.
That summer, I became deeply immersed in Duolingo, driven by daily app notifications comparing my progress with friends and accumulating points. The app’s mascot, an owl, would even send emails expressing “disapproval” and “sadness” on days I missed lessons, a form of emotional persuasion that often spurred me back into action during any free moment. By summer’s end, I had completed the entire Duolingo Chinese tree.
However, despite this dedication, fluency remained elusive. My spoken Mandarin was still at a basic elementary level, A1 on the European framework. This experience came to mind recently when a Spanish-learning friend, also a Duolingo enthusiast, shared an article defending the app against criticism. Duolingo has faced mockery online, with users sharing bizarre, impractical sentences encountered in lessons.
Why “Silly Sentences” Aren’t the Key to Mastering Mandarin
Duolingo’s article, ‘How silly sentences can help you learn’, argues that these strange sentences are intentionally memorable, serving as “grammatical anchors” to aid in remembering key concepts and accurate communication. They suggest communication is about “learning rules and flexibility.”
I disagree with this approach, especially for a language like Mandarin. Effective communication in Chinese isn’t primarily about isolated grammar rules learned through unnatural sentences. The “memorability” of a sentence is irrelevant if it’s not how native speakers communicate. Instead, the focus should be on repeated exposure to comprehensible, natural language in relevant contexts. Immersion in authentic Mandarin is crucial for internalizing grammar patterns organically.
Years of studying effective Mandarin learning methods have shown me that the best way to truly grasp grammar is by consuming large amounts of comprehensible content. Techniques like sentence mining help learners collect relevant phrases and structures, which can then be actively used in real-life situations.
Better Tools for Learning Mandarin: Beyond Duolingo
Alternative resources like graded readers offer a more effective immersion in grammar patterns than Duolingo. Graded readers are designed for learners with limited vocabulary to engage in extensive reading, unlike Duolingo’s isolated sentence approach. Compelling stories and articles in graded readers are far more engaging and effective than Duolingo’s often-random sentences.
Soon after my Duolingo phase, I discovered Mandarin Companion graded readers starting from just 150 words. LingQ also provides mini-stories for beginners. Had I known about these resources earlier, I would have moved on from Duolingo sooner. These tools, combined with consistent speaking practice, were instrumental in my journey to fluency, not Duolingo.
Duolingo’s Limited Usefulness in Learning Mandarin
Duolingo does have a limited role to play, primarily in initial vocabulary building. It can introduce basic phrases, such as how to say hello in Mandarin, and bridge the gap for learners with very limited vocabulary before they can access meaningful content like graded readers and Mandarin novels.
However, even for vocabulary, Duolingo is insufficient alone. Reading Chinese necessitates learning Chinese characters. Spaced Repetition Systems (SRS) flashcards are far more effective for character memorization. While Duolingo includes some character tasks, they are not comprehensive enough for effective retention. Therefore, Duolingo users should supplement their learning with character flashcards or gamified SRS tools like Ninchanese.
Furthermore, while Duolingo introduces Chinese tones, its tone instruction was inadequate for me to develop a solid grasp. Even after completing the Duolingo tree, my tone accuracy remained limited, requiring significant later effort to correct.
My Verdict on Duolingo for Mandarin: Proceed with Caution
Looking back, I don’t entirely regret using Duolingo. However, I do regret the obsession and the naive belief that it would lead to fluency. If I could restart, I would use Duolingo briefly, alongside flashcards and other vocabulary tools, just long enough to prepare for engaging with more meaningful Mandarin content. Then, I would move on to more effective methods for truly learning Mandarin.
Ready to Speak Mandarin Clearly? Start with Your Tones!
My experience taught me that mastering Mandarin tones is fundamental. Sign up below for the Tones Mechanic – a free newsletter where I share the exact steps I used to refine my tones for confident and natural Mandarin speaking, even in public speeches and podcasts.
Subscribing also grants you free access to a complete Tones Masterclass video course, packed with step-by-step lessons and native audio examples. Begin your journey to tone mastery today!
Mischa Wilmers
Share this:
- Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
- Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
Like this:
Like Loading…
