What Is Transformational Learning And How To Apply It?

Transformational learning, a profound approach to education, empowers individuals to critically examine their assumptions and beliefs, fostering significant shifts in perspective, and at LEARNS.EDU.VN, we are dedicated to illuminating this transformative process. This method goes beyond rote memorization, encouraging learners to actively engage with new information, challenge their existing viewpoints, and ultimately, evolve their understanding of themselves and the world. Delve into the depths of this pedagogical approach, exploring its core principles, practical applications, and the profound impact it can have on personal and intellectual growth with our comprehensive guide. Discover how to unlock its full potential through techniques such as perspective-shifting activities, assumption-challenging exercises, and critical discourse facilitation, and join LEARNS.EDU.VN in a journey of intellectual discovery and personal evolution.

1. Understanding Transformational Learning

Transformational learning is a theory that explains how adults learn and change their perspectives. It goes beyond simply acquiring new information; it involves a fundamental shift in how individuals perceive themselves and the world around them. This type of learning is particularly relevant in today’s rapidly changing world, where individuals are constantly faced with new challenges and opportunities that require them to adapt and evolve.

1.1. Definition of Transformational Learning

Transformational learning is a process by which individuals critically examine their assumptions, beliefs, and values, and revise them based on new experiences and insights. This process often involves a disorienting dilemma, which challenges the individual’s existing worldview and creates a need for change. According to Jack Mezirow, who developed the theory of transformational learning, this type of learning involves a “shift in perspective” that leads to “more discriminating, open, permeable, and better justified” understandings.

1.2. Key Principles of Transformational Learning

Several key principles underpin the theory of transformational learning:

  • Critical Reflection: This involves examining one’s assumptions and beliefs, questioning their validity, and considering alternative perspectives.
  • Rational Discourse: Engaging in open and honest dialogue with others to explore different viewpoints and challenge one’s own thinking.
  • Experience: Learning from real-life experiences, both positive and negative, and using them as opportunities for growth.
  • Perspective Transformation: The ultimate goal of transformational learning, which involves a fundamental shift in one’s worldview and a more inclusive and nuanced understanding of the world.

1.3. The Process of Transformational Learning

Mezirow outlined a ten-phase process of transformational learning:

  1. A disorienting dilemma: An event that challenges the learner’s existing worldview.
  2. Self-examination: A critical assessment of one’s assumptions and beliefs.
  3. A sense of alienation: Feeling disconnected from one’s previous way of thinking.
  4. Relating discontent: Connecting one’s discontent with similar experiences of others.
  5. Exploration of options: Considering new ways of thinking and acting.
  6. Planning a course of action: Developing a strategy for implementing new perspectives.
  7. Acquiring knowledge and skills: Gaining the necessary tools to support the new perspective.
  8. Provisional efforts: Trying out new roles and behaviors.
  9. Evaluation: Assessing the impact of the new perspective.
  10. A reintegration: Integrating the new perspective into one’s life.

1.4. Benefits of Transformational Learning

Transformational learning offers numerous benefits, including:

  • Enhanced Critical Thinking: Developing the ability to analyze information, identify biases, and form well-reasoned judgments.
  • Increased Self-Awareness: Gaining a deeper understanding of one’s values, beliefs, and motivations.
  • Improved Problem-Solving Skills: Developing the ability to approach challenges from multiple perspectives and find creative solutions.
  • Greater Empathy and Understanding: Cultivating the capacity to appreciate diverse viewpoints and connect with others on a deeper level.
  • Personal Growth and Empowerment: Experiencing a sense of liberation and empowerment as one sheds limiting beliefs and embraces new possibilities.

2. Applying Transformational Learning in Education

Transformational learning can be effectively integrated into educational settings to foster deeper learning and personal growth among students of all ages. By creating opportunities for critical reflection, dialogue, and experience, educators can empower students to challenge their assumptions, broaden their perspectives, and become more engaged and self-directed learners.

2.1. Creating a Transformative Learning Environment

To foster transformational learning, educators need to create a classroom environment that is:

  • Safe and Supportive: Students should feel comfortable expressing their opinions, even if they differ from others, without fear of judgment or ridicule.
  • Challenging and Stimulating: The curriculum should present students with complex and thought-provoking issues that encourage them to question their assumptions and explore new perspectives.
  • Collaborative and Interactive: Students should have opportunities to work together, share their ideas, and learn from each other.
  • Reflective and Introspective: Students should be encouraged to reflect on their learning experiences, identify their assumptions, and consider how their perspectives have changed.

2.2. Strategies for Promoting Transformational Learning

Educators can use a variety of strategies to promote transformational learning in the classroom:

  • Provide Opportunities for Perspective-Taking: Expose students to diverse viewpoints through literature, films, guest speakers, and simulations.
  • Encourage Critical Reflection: Use journaling, reflective writing prompts, and class discussions to help students examine their assumptions and beliefs.
  • Facilitate Dialogue and Debate: Create opportunities for students to engage in respectful and constructive dialogue about controversial issues.
  • Promote Experiential Learning: Engage students in hands-on activities, field trips, and community service projects that provide real-world learning experiences.
  • Offer Feedback and Support: Provide students with constructive feedback on their work and offer support as they grapple with challenging concepts and perspectives.

2.3. Transformative Learning Activities

Here are some specific activities that educators can use to promote transformational learning:

  • Case Studies: Analyze real-world case studies that present complex ethical dilemmas and require students to consider multiple perspectives.
  • Role-Playing: Have students role-play different characters in a historical event or social situation to gain a deeper understanding of their perspectives.
  • Debates: Organize debates on controversial issues, requiring students to research and present arguments from different viewpoints.
  • Service Learning Projects: Engage students in community service projects that address social issues and provide opportunities for them to interact with diverse populations.
  • Reflective Journals: Have students keep reflective journals in which they record their thoughts, feelings, and insights about their learning experiences.

2.4. Examples of Transformational Learning in Practice

Here are some examples of how transformational learning can be applied in different subject areas:

  • History: Students can examine historical events from multiple perspectives, considering the experiences of different groups and challenging dominant narratives.
  • Literature: Students can analyze literary works that explore complex social and ethical issues, examining the motivations and perspectives of different characters.
  • Science: Students can investigate the social and ethical implications of scientific discoveries, considering the potential benefits and risks of new technologies.
  • Social Studies: Students can engage in simulations of political or economic systems, experiencing the challenges and trade-offs involved in decision-making.

3. Transformational Learning in Adult Education

Transformational learning is particularly relevant in adult education, as adults often come to learning experiences with deeply ingrained beliefs and values. By providing opportunities for critical reflection and dialogue, adult educators can help learners challenge their assumptions, broaden their perspectives, and achieve personal and professional growth.

3.1. The Importance of Transformational Learning for Adults

Adults often face unique challenges in learning, such as:

  • Prior Experiences: Adults bring a wealth of life experiences to the learning environment, which can both enrich and hinder their learning.
  • Fixed Beliefs: Adults may have deeply ingrained beliefs and values that are difficult to change.
  • Time Constraints: Adults often have limited time for learning due to work, family, and other commitments.
  • Motivation: Adults may have different motivations for learning than younger students, such as career advancement, personal enrichment, or social engagement.

Transformational learning can help adults overcome these challenges by providing them with the tools and support they need to:

  • Challenge Their Assumptions: Critically examine their existing beliefs and values and consider alternative perspectives.
  • Adapt to Change: Develop the ability to adapt to new situations and embrace new opportunities.
  • Achieve Personal Growth: Experience a sense of liberation and empowerment as they shed limiting beliefs and embrace new possibilities.
  • Enhance Their Professional Skills: Develop the critical thinking, problem-solving, and communication skills that are essential for success in today’s workplace.

3.2. Strategies for Facilitating Transformational Learning in Adults

Adult educators can use a variety of strategies to facilitate transformational learning:

  • Create a Safe and Supportive Learning Environment: Foster a climate of trust and respect where learners feel comfortable sharing their thoughts and feelings.
  • Use Experiential Learning Activities: Engage learners in hands-on activities, simulations, and case studies that provide real-world learning experiences.
  • Encourage Critical Reflection: Use journaling, reflective writing prompts, and group discussions to help learners examine their assumptions and beliefs.
  • Provide Feedback and Support: Offer learners constructive feedback on their work and provide support as they grapple with challenging concepts and perspectives.
  • Connect Learning to Real-Life Situations: Help learners see the relevance of the material to their own lives and work.

3.3. Examples of Transformational Learning in Adult Education

Here are some examples of how transformational learning can be applied in adult education:

  • Leadership Development Programs: Help leaders develop the self-awareness, empathy, and critical thinking skills they need to lead effectively.
  • Diversity and Inclusion Training: Promote understanding and respect for diverse perspectives and cultures.
  • Career Development Workshops: Help individuals identify their strengths, values, and interests and develop a plan for achieving their career goals.
  • Personal Growth Seminars: Provide opportunities for individuals to explore their values, beliefs, and motivations and develop a greater sense of self-awareness and purpose.

4. Challenges and Criticisms of Transformational Learning

While transformational learning offers numerous benefits, it is not without its challenges and criticisms. Some common concerns include:

4.1. The Difficulty of Measuring Transformation

Transformation is a complex and subjective process that is difficult to measure objectively. It can be challenging to determine whether a learner has truly undergone a transformative experience or has simply adopted new behaviors without fundamentally changing their beliefs or values.

4.2. The Potential for Emotional Distress

Transformational learning can be emotionally challenging, as it requires learners to confront their deeply ingrained beliefs and values. This process can be unsettling and even distressing for some individuals, particularly those who have experienced trauma or have a strong attachment to their existing worldview.

4.3. The Risk of Imposing One’s Own Values

Some critics argue that transformational learning can be used to impose one’s own values or beliefs on others. Educators need to be mindful of this risk and ensure that they are creating a learning environment that is truly open and respectful of diverse perspectives.

4.4. The Lack of Empirical Evidence

While there is a growing body of research on transformational learning, some critics argue that there is a lack of rigorous empirical evidence to support its effectiveness. More research is needed to determine the specific conditions under which transformational learning is most likely to occur and the long-term impact it has on learners.

4.5. Addressing the Challenges

Despite these challenges, transformational learning remains a valuable approach to education and personal development. By being aware of the potential pitfalls and taking steps to mitigate them, educators can create learning experiences that are both transformative and empowering. Here are some strategies for addressing the challenges of transformational learning:

  • Focus on Process, Not Outcome: Emphasize the importance of critical reflection, dialogue, and experience, rather than trying to force a specific outcome.
  • Provide Support and Guidance: Offer learners with support and guidance as they grapple with challenging concepts and perspectives.
  • Respect Diversity of Perspectives: Create a learning environment that is open and respectful of diverse viewpoints.
  • Use a Variety of Assessment Methods: Use a variety of assessment methods to measure learning, including self-reflection, peer feedback, and performance-based tasks.
  • Stay Informed About Research: Stay informed about the latest research on transformational learning and use evidence-based practices in the classroom.

5. Enhancing Your Learning Experience with LEARNS.EDU.VN

At LEARNS.EDU.VN, we understand the transformative power of education. We provide a wide range of resources and tools to help you embark on your own journey of intellectual discovery and personal growth. Our platform offers:

5.1. Comprehensive Educational Resources

LEARNS.EDU.VN offers a wealth of educational resources, including:

  • Articles and Guides: In-depth articles and guides on a variety of topics, designed to expand your knowledge and understanding.
  • Courses and Tutorials: Engaging courses and tutorials that cover a wide range of subjects, from academic disciplines to practical skills.
  • Expert Insights: Access to insights and perspectives from leading experts in various fields.
  • Interactive Learning Tools: Interactive tools and simulations that make learning fun and engaging.

5.2. Personalized Learning Paths

We recognize that every learner is unique, with their own individual goals, interests, and learning styles. That’s why we offer personalized learning paths that are tailored to your specific needs. Our platform uses advanced algorithms to:

  • Assess Your Knowledge: Evaluate your current knowledge and skills in various areas.
  • Identify Your Goals: Help you identify your learning goals and objectives.
  • Recommend Resources: Recommend the most relevant resources and activities to help you achieve your goals.
  • Track Your Progress: Monitor your progress and provide feedback to keep you motivated and on track.

5.3. A Community of Learners

LEARNS.EDU.VN is more than just a platform for learning; it’s a community of learners. We provide opportunities for you to connect with other learners, share your ideas, and learn from each other. Our community features include:

  • Discussion Forums: Participate in discussion forums on a variety of topics.
  • Study Groups: Join or create study groups to collaborate with other learners.
  • Expert Q&A Sessions: Participate in Q&A sessions with leading experts in various fields.
  • Social Networking: Connect with other learners on social media.

5.4. How LEARNS.EDU.VN Supports Transformational Learning

LEARNS.EDU.VN is designed to support transformational learning by:

  • Providing Diverse Perspectives: Offering a wide range of perspectives on various topics, encouraging you to challenge your assumptions and broaden your understanding.
  • Promoting Critical Reflection: Providing opportunities for you to reflect on your learning experiences and examine your beliefs and values.
  • Facilitating Dialogue and Debate: Creating a platform for you to engage in respectful and constructive dialogue with other learners.
  • Encouraging Experiential Learning: Providing opportunities for you to apply your knowledge and skills in real-world situations.

6. The Future of Transformational Learning

Transformational learning is poised to play an increasingly important role in education and personal development in the years to come. As the world becomes more complex and rapidly changing, the ability to think critically, adapt to new situations, and embrace diverse perspectives will be essential for success.

6.1. Emerging Trends in Transformational Learning

Several emerging trends are shaping the future of transformational learning:

  • Technology-Enhanced Learning: The use of technology to create more engaging, personalized, and accessible learning experiences.
  • Personalized Learning: Tailoring learning experiences to the individual needs, interests, and learning styles of each learner.
  • Competency-Based Education: Focusing on the development of specific skills and competencies, rather than simply acquiring knowledge.
  • Lifelong Learning: Recognizing that learning is a continuous process that extends beyond formal education.
  • Social and Emotional Learning: Integrating social and emotional skills into the curriculum to promote well-being and resilience.

6.2. The Role of Technology in Transformational Learning

Technology can play a powerful role in enhancing transformational learning by:

  • Providing Access to Diverse Perspectives: Connecting learners with diverse viewpoints and experiences from around the world.
  • Facilitating Collaboration and Communication: Enabling learners to collaborate and communicate with each other in real-time.
  • Creating Immersive Learning Experiences: Providing immersive learning experiences through virtual reality, augmented reality, and simulations.
  • Personalizing Learning: Tailoring learning experiences to the individual needs and interests of each learner.
  • Tracking Progress and Providing Feedback: Monitoring learner progress and providing personalized feedback to support their learning.

6.3. The Importance of Lifelong Learning

In today’s rapidly changing world, lifelong learning is more important than ever. Individuals need to continuously acquire new knowledge and skills to stay relevant in the workforce, adapt to new technologies, and navigate complex social and environmental challenges. Transformational learning can help individuals develop the skills and mindset they need to become lifelong learners:

  • Curiosity: A desire to learn and explore new ideas.
  • Critical Thinking: The ability to analyze information, identify biases, and form well-reasoned judgments.
  • Adaptability: The ability to adapt to new situations and embrace new opportunities.
  • Resilience: The ability to bounce back from setbacks and challenges.
  • Self-Direction: The ability to take ownership of one’s own learning and development.

6.4. Transformational Learning for a Better Future

Transformational learning has the potential to create a better future for individuals, communities, and the world as a whole. By fostering critical thinking, empathy, and a commitment to social justice, transformational learning can empower individuals to:

  • Solve Complex Problems: Address pressing social, economic, and environmental challenges.
  • Promote Social Justice: Advocate for equality, fairness, and human rights.
  • Build Stronger Communities: Foster collaboration, understanding, and respect among diverse groups of people.
  • Create a More Sustainable World: Promote environmental stewardship and responsible consumption.

7. Practical Tips for Embracing Transformational Learning

Embracing transformational learning can seem daunting, but with the right approach, it can be a rewarding and empowering experience. Here are some practical tips to help you get started:

7.1. Cultivate a Growth Mindset

A growth mindset is the belief that your abilities and intelligence can be developed through dedication and hard work. This mindset is essential for transformational learning, as it allows you to embrace challenges, learn from mistakes, and persist in the face of setbacks. Here are some ways to cultivate a growth mindset:

  • Embrace Challenges: View challenges as opportunities for growth and learning.
  • Learn from Mistakes: See mistakes as valuable learning experiences, rather than as failures.
  • Persist in the Face of Setbacks: Don’t give up when you encounter difficulties; keep trying and learning.
  • Value Effort Over Talent: Recognize that effort and hard work are more important than innate talent.
  • Seek Feedback: Ask for feedback from others and use it to improve your performance.

7.2. Practice Self-Reflection

Self-reflection is the process of examining your thoughts, feelings, and behaviors to gain a deeper understanding of yourself. This practice is crucial for transformational learning, as it allows you to identify your assumptions, challenge your beliefs, and develop a more nuanced perspective. Here are some ways to practice self-reflection:

  • Journaling: Write down your thoughts, feelings, and experiences in a journal.
  • Meditation: Practice mindfulness meditation to become more aware of your thoughts and feelings.
  • Self-Assessment: Use self-assessment tools to evaluate your strengths, weaknesses, and values.
  • Seek Feedback: Ask for feedback from others about your behavior and performance.
  • Reflect on Your Experiences: Take time to reflect on your experiences and identify what you have learned.

7.3. Seek Out Diverse Perspectives

Exposing yourself to diverse perspectives is essential for challenging your assumptions and broadening your understanding of the world. Here are some ways to seek out diverse perspectives:

  • Read Widely: Read books, articles, and blogs from a variety of sources.
  • Travel: Travel to different countries and cultures to experience new ways of life.
  • Attend Events: Attend cultural events, lectures, and workshops that expose you to diverse perspectives.
  • Connect with People: Connect with people from different backgrounds and cultures.
  • Listen Actively: Listen actively to others and try to understand their perspectives.

7.4. Engage in Dialogue

Engaging in dialogue with others is a powerful way to challenge your assumptions, learn from different perspectives, and develop a more nuanced understanding of complex issues. Here are some tips for engaging in dialogue:

  • Listen Actively: Pay attention to what others are saying and try to understand their perspectives.
  • Ask Open-Ended Questions: Ask questions that encourage others to share their thoughts and feelings.
  • Share Your Own Perspective: Share your own thoughts and feelings in a respectful and constructive manner.
  • Be Open to Changing Your Mind: Be willing to change your mind if you hear a compelling argument.
  • Focus on Understanding: Focus on understanding each other’s perspectives, rather than trying to win the argument.

7.5. Embrace Discomfort

Transformational learning often involves discomfort, as it requires you to challenge your deeply ingrained beliefs and values. Embracing discomfort is essential for growth and learning. Here are some tips for embracing discomfort:

  • Recognize That Discomfort Is Temporary: Understand that discomfort is a temporary feeling that will eventually pass.
  • Focus on the Benefits of Growth: Focus on the benefits of growth and learning, rather than on the discomfort.
  • Challenge Your Negative Thoughts: Challenge your negative thoughts and replace them with positive ones.
  • Seek Support: Seek support from friends, family, or a therapist.
  • Practice Self-Care: Practice self-care activities to manage stress and anxiety.

8. Case Studies of Transformational Learning

Real-life examples can vividly illustrate the power and impact of transformational learning. Here are a few case studies that demonstrate how individuals have experienced profound shifts in perspective and understanding through this process:

8.1. From Skeptic to Advocate: A Climate Change Transformation

Sarah, a business student, initially dismissed climate change as an exaggerated environmental concern. Through a university course that presented scientific evidence, personal stories from affected communities, and opportunities to engage in debates, Sarah began to question her assumptions.

  • Disorienting Dilemma: Exposure to the stark realities of climate change and its impact on vulnerable populations.
  • Critical Reflection: Researching the scientific consensus and examining her own biases.
  • Perspective Transformation: Recognizing the urgency of the issue and becoming a passionate advocate for climate action.

8.2. Overcoming Bias: A Journey Towards Inclusivity

David, a middle-aged engineer, held unconscious biases toward certain ethnic groups due to limited exposure and societal stereotypes. A diversity and inclusion workshop at his workplace provided him with tools for self-reflection and opportunities to engage in open dialogue with colleagues from diverse backgrounds.

  • Disorienting Dilemma: Realizing the impact of his biases on his interactions with colleagues.
  • Critical Reflection: Examining the origins of his biases and challenging the validity of stereotypes.
  • Perspective Transformation: Developing a deeper understanding and appreciation for diversity and becoming an active ally for inclusivity.

8.3. Finding Purpose: A Career Transformation

Emily, a lawyer, felt unfulfilled despite her professional success. After attending a personal growth seminar that encouraged her to explore her values and passions, she realized that her career was not aligned with her true calling.

  • Disorienting Dilemma: Experiencing a sense of disconnect and lack of purpose in her current career.
  • Critical Reflection: Identifying her core values and passions and exploring alternative career paths.
  • Perspective Transformation: Leaving her law practice and pursuing a career in social work, where she could make a positive impact on the lives of others.

8.4. The Common Thread

These case studies highlight the key elements of transformational learning:

  • A Triggering Event: A disorienting dilemma that challenges existing assumptions.
  • Critical Self-Reflection: A willingness to examine one’s beliefs and values.
  • Open Dialogue: Engaging with diverse perspectives and challenging one’s own thinking.
  • A Shift in Perspective: A fundamental change in understanding and worldview.
  • Action and Integration: Translating new insights into meaningful action and integrating them into one’s life.

These examples demonstrate that transformational learning is not just a theoretical concept but a powerful process that can lead to profound personal and social change.

9. Conclusion: Embracing the Power of Transformational Learning

Transformational learning is a powerful approach to education and personal development that can empower individuals to challenge their assumptions, broaden their perspectives, and achieve meaningful change in their lives. By creating learning environments that are safe, challenging, and collaborative, educators can foster transformational learning in students of all ages.

9.1. The Enduring Relevance of Transformational Learning

In a world that is constantly evolving, the ability to adapt, learn, and grow is more important than ever. Transformational learning provides individuals with the tools and skills they need to navigate complexity, embrace diversity, and create a better future for themselves and their communities.

9.2. Your Journey Starts Now

We invite you to explore the resources and opportunities available at LEARNS.EDU.VN to embark on your own journey of transformational learning. Whether you are a student, educator, or lifelong learner, we are here to support you in your quest for knowledge, growth, and personal empowerment.

9.3. Further Exploration at LEARNS.EDU.VN

Ready to take the next step? Visit LEARNS.EDU.VN today to:

  • Explore our comprehensive library of articles and guides on transformational learning and related topics.
  • Discover courses and tutorials designed to help you develop the skills and mindset you need to become a transformational learner.
  • Connect with a community of learners who are passionate about personal growth and intellectual discovery.
  • Learn more about our personalized learning paths and how we can help you achieve your unique goals.

Join us at LEARNS.EDU.VN and unlock the transformative power of education.

Address: 123 Education Way, Learnville, CA 90210, United States

Whatsapp: +1 555-555-1212

Website: learns.edu.vn

10. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Transformational Learning

Here are some frequently asked questions about transformational learning to help you deepen your understanding:

  1. What is the main focus of transformational learning?
    Transformational learning primarily focuses on fostering critical reflection and perspective transformation in learners.

  2. How does transformational learning differ from traditional learning methods?
    Unlike traditional learning, which emphasizes rote memorization, transformational learning encourages learners to challenge assumptions and revise their beliefs.

  3. What role does experience play in transformational learning?
    Experience is crucial in transformational learning, serving as a catalyst for learners to re-evaluate their perspectives based on real-life situations.

  4. Can transformational learning be applied in all educational settings?
    Yes, transformational learning can be applied in various educational settings to promote deeper learning and personal growth across different age groups.

  5. What are some strategies to facilitate transformational learning in adults?
    Creating a safe learning environment, using experiential activities, and encouraging critical reflection are effective strategies for facilitating transformational learning in adults.

  6. How can educators create a transformative learning environment?
    Educators can create a transformative learning environment by fostering a safe, challenging, collaborative, and reflective atmosphere in the classroom.

  7. What are the key principles that underpin transformational learning?
    The key principles include critical reflection, rational discourse, experience, and the ultimate goal of perspective transformation.

  8. What is a ‘disorienting dilemma’ in the context of transformational learning?
    A ‘disorienting dilemma’ is an event that challenges a learner’s existing worldview and creates a need for change and perspective transformation.

  9. How does technology enhance transformational learning?
    Technology enhances transformational learning by providing access to diverse perspectives, facilitating collaboration, and creating immersive learning experiences.

  10. What skills do individuals need to become lifelong transformational learners?
    Individuals need curiosity, critical thinking, adaptability, resilience, and self-direction to become lifelong transformational learners.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *