Learned Helplessness Definition: Understanding the Psychology of Giving Up

Learned helplessness is a psychological condition that arises when individuals or animals, after repeatedly facing uncontrollable and adverse situations, begin to believe that they have no power to change their circumstances. This belief leads to a sense of futility, causing them to stop trying to exert control or seek solutions, even when opportunities for positive change become available.

In animal behavior studies, the concept of learned helplessness is often demonstrated when an animal is repeatedly exposed to an unpleasant stimulus, such as an electric shock, that it cannot escape. Initially, the animal may attempt to avoid the shock. However, after repeated failures, it learns to become passive and accept the stimulus, even if escape becomes possible. This state of resignation is learned helplessness.

While initially observed and studied in animals, learned helplessness is a concept that profoundly applies to human psychology. When people repeatedly encounter situations where their actions seem to have no impact on outcomes, they can develop a similar sense of helplessness. This can manifest in various aspects of life, from academic and professional performance to personal relationships and mental well-being. For instance, a student consistently failing exams despite diligent study may develop learned helplessness, believing that effort is futile and academic success is unattainable.

This article will delve into the definition of learned helplessness, exploring its symptoms, the seminal research that established the concept, the underlying causes, and effective strategies for overcoming this debilitating psychological state. We aim to provide a comprehensive understanding of learned helplessness and empower individuals to recognize and address its impact on their lives.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/GettyImages-140732947-56a04bbd5f9b58eba4b1c18a.jpg)

Symptoms of Learned Helplessness

Learned helplessness is characterized by a range of behavioral and emotional symptoms. While everyone experiences setbacks and challenges, learned helplessness involves persistent and pervasive signs that indicate a deeper sense of resignation and lack of control. These symptoms can significantly impact daily life and overall well-being. Common symptoms of learned helplessness include:

Avoiding decisions: Fear of making choices, stemming from a belief that outcomes are predetermined and personal actions are irrelevant.
Negative attitude: A pessimistic outlook on life, characterized by hopelessness and a lack of belief in positive change.
Giving up easily: A tendency to abandon tasks or goals at the first sign of difficulty, believing that effort is pointless.
Low frustration tolerance: Inability to cope with setbacks or obstacles, leading to rapid discouragement and resignation.
Lack of effort: Reduced motivation and initiative to engage in activities, as individuals believe their efforts will not lead to desired results.
Low motivation: Diminished drive and enthusiasm for pursuing goals or engaging in activities that were once enjoyable.
Passive behavior: A general lack of assertiveness and proactivity, accepting situations without attempting to change them.
Poor self-esteem: Negative self-perception and a lack of confidence in one’s abilities, often resulting from repeated failures.
Procrastination: Delaying tasks and responsibilities, driven by a belief that success is unattainable regardless of effort.
Refusal to try: Complete unwillingness to attempt new tasks or challenges, based on the expectation of failure.

It is important to note that learned helplessness, while not a formal mental health diagnosis in itself, can be a significant indicator of underlying mental health conditions such as depression and anxiety disorders. If you recognize these symptoms in yourself or someone you know, seeking professional guidance is advisable.

The Discovery of Learned Helplessness: The Dog Shock Experiment

The concept of learned helplessness emerged from accidental discoveries made by psychologists Martin Seligman and Steven F. Maier during their research on classical conditioning in dogs. Initially, they were studying how dogs learned to associate a tone with an impending electric shock.

In their early experiments, dogs were placed in harnesses and subjected to electric shocks after hearing a specific tone. Later, these dogs were introduced to a shuttlebox, a divided chamber where they could escape shocks by jumping over a low barrier to the safe side. Surprisingly, dogs that had previously experienced inescapable shocks in the harness did not attempt to escape the shocks in the shuttlebox. Even though a simple jump could have brought relief, they remained passive and endured the shocks.

To further investigate this unexpected behavior, Seligman and Maier designed a refined experiment involving three groups of dogs:

Group One (Control Group): Dogs were placed in harnesses for a period of time but received no shocks.
Group Two (Escape Group): Dogs were placed in harnesses and received electric shocks, but they could learn to stop the shocks by pressing a panel with their noses. This group had control over the shocks.
Group Three (Inescapable Shock Group): Dogs were placed in harnesses and received electric shocks of the same intensity and duration as Group Two. However, they had no way to control or stop the shocks. The shocks appeared random and uncontrollable to them.

Subsequently, all three groups of dogs were placed in the shuttlebox. Dogs from the control group (Group One) and the escape group (Group Two) quickly learned to jump over the barrier to avoid the shocks. However, the dogs from the inescapable shock group (Group Three) displayed learned helplessness. They made no attempts to escape the shocks in the shuttlebox, behaving as if their actions were futile.

Seligman and Maier’s experiments demonstrated that the dogs who experienced inescapable shocks developed learned helplessness. Their prior experience led them to form a “cognitive expectation” that nothing they did could prevent or eliminate the unpleasant shocks. This cognitive expectation, rather than the shocks themselves, was the key factor in their helpless behavior.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/martin-seligman-56a04b625f9b58eba4b1bdf1.jpg)

Causes of Learned Helplessness: Trauma and Lack of Control

Learned helplessness frequently arises from experiences of significant stress or trauma, particularly situations where individuals perceive a lack of control over their environment and outcomes. This perceived lack of control is central to the development of learned helplessness, leading individuals to believe that their actions are ineffective in altering negative situations.

Common experiences and situations that can contribute to learned helplessness include:

Abuse: Physical, emotional, or verbal abuse, which can create a sense of powerlessness and lack of control in the victim.
Childhood neglect: Lack of consistent care, support, and responsiveness from caregivers, leading to a child’s belief that their needs and actions have no impact.
Chronic illness: Dealing with a long-term illness that feels uncontrollable and overwhelming, fostering a sense of helplessness.
Domestic violence: Experiencing violence and control within a domestic setting, leading to a perception of being trapped and unable to escape.
Natural disasters: Facing events like earthquakes, floods, or hurricanes, which are inherently uncontrollable and can instill feelings of helplessness.
Trauma: Experiencing any deeply distressing or disturbing event that overwhelms coping mechanisms and creates a sense of vulnerability and lack of control.

Interestingly, overparenting, while seemingly benevolent, can also contribute to learned helplessness in children. When parents excessively control and intervene in their children’s lives, preventing them from facing challenges and learning to solve problems independently, children may develop a diminished sense of personal agency. They may internalize a belief that they are incapable of handling difficulties on their own, leading to learned helplessness.

The development of learned helplessness involves three key elements:

Contingency: This refers to the objective relationship between actions and outcomes. In learned helplessness situations, there is a lack of contingency – actions do not reliably lead to desired outcomes.
Cognition: This involves how individuals perceive and interpret the contingency (or lack thereof). Learned helplessness arises when individuals believe there is no relationship between their actions and outcomes, even if some control might be possible.
Behavior: This refers to the actions individuals take (or fail to take) based on their cognitive interpretation of contingency. In learned helplessness, the behavior is characterized by passivity and inaction, as individuals believe effort is futile.

The Role of Explanatory Styles: Pessimism and Helplessness

While exposure to uncontrollable events is a primary factor in learned helplessness, individual differences in explanatory styles also play a significant role in determining vulnerability to this phenomenon. Explanatory style, also known as attributional style, refers to an individual’s characteristic way of explaining the causes of events, particularly negative ones.

A pessimistic explanatory style is strongly linked to an increased susceptibility to learned helplessness. Individuals with a pessimistic explanatory style tend to attribute negative events to internal, stable, and global causes:

Internal: They blame themselves for negative events (“It’s my fault”).
Stable: They believe the causes of negative events are permanent and unchanging (“This will always be a problem”).
Global: They believe the causes of negative events affect many areas of their lives (“This affects everything I do”).

This pessimistic outlook fosters a sense of hopelessness and uncontrollability, making individuals more prone to developing learned helplessness when facing adversity. Conversely, an optimistic explanatory style, where negative events are attributed to external, unstable, and specific causes, can act as a protective factor against learned helplessness.

Impact of Learned Helplessness: Across Life Domains

The impact of learned helplessness is far-reaching, affecting various aspects of life and well-being. While initially studied in animal models, the detrimental effects of learned helplessness are evident in human experiences as well.

Consider the common example of academic performance. A child consistently struggling with math, despite dedicated study and effort, may begin to believe that academic success in math is unattainable. This learned helplessness in the academic domain can generalize to other areas, leading to a broader sense of inadequacy and diminished motivation. When faced with any math-related task, they are likely to feel hopeless and incapable, hindering their ability to learn and progress.

Beyond academic settings, learned helplessness is strongly associated with several psychological disorders. It is a significant contributing factor to:

Depression: Learned helplessness is considered a core component of depressive disorders, characterized by feelings of hopelessness, sadness, and lack of motivation.
Anxiety disorders: Learned helplessness can exacerbate anxiety, as individuals feel powerless to manage or control their anxious feelings and situations that trigger anxiety.
Phobias: Learned helplessness can maintain phobias, as individuals believe they are unable to overcome their fears and avoid feared situations, reinforcing avoidance behaviors.
Shyness and social anxiety: Learned helplessness can amplify shyness and social anxiety, as individuals feel unable to improve their social skills or overcome social discomfort, leading to social withdrawal.
Loneliness: Learned helplessness can contribute to loneliness, as individuals believe they are unable to form meaningful connections or improve their social relationships, leading to isolation.

For example, someone experiencing shyness in social situations may develop learned helplessness regarding their social abilities. Feeling that they cannot overcome their shyness, they may stop trying to engage socially, further reinforcing their shyness and isolation.

However, research also indicates that learned helplessness is not always generalized across all settings and situations. An individual experiencing learned helplessness in math class might not necessarily exhibit the same helplessness in other areas, such as sports or art. In some cases, learned helplessness can be situation-specific, while in other instances, it can generalize to a wider range of life domains.

Learned Helplessness in Children: Early Origins

Learned helplessness can often originate in childhood, with early experiences of unresponsiveness and lack of control playing a crucial role in its development. Unreliable or unresponsive caregivers can significantly contribute to children developing these feelings of helplessness. This learned pattern can begin very early in life, even during infancy.

Children raised in institutionalized settings, for example, where individual attention and responsive care may be limited, often exhibit symptoms of helplessness from a young age. When children’s cries for help or needs for attention are consistently ignored or unmet, they can internalize a belief that their actions have no impact on their environment or the people around them.

Repeated experiences that reinforce these feelings of helplessness and hopelessness during childhood can have long-lasting effects, leading to individuals growing into adulthood with a persistent sense that they are unable to change their problems or improve their lives.

Common symptoms of learned helplessness in children include:

Failure to ask for help: Reluctance to seek assistance, believing that help will not be forthcoming or effective.
Frustration: Easily becoming frustrated and overwhelmed when faced with challenges, due to a low frustration tolerance and belief in futility.
Giving up easily: Quickly abandoning tasks or activities when encountering difficulty, reinforcing a pattern of avoidance and resignation.
Lack of effort: Reduced motivation and initiative in schoolwork or other activities, stemming from a belief that effort is pointless.
Low self-esteem: Negative self-perception and lack of confidence, often exacerbated by academic struggles and perceived failures.
Passivity: A general lack of proactivity and assertiveness, accepting situations without attempting to influence them.
Poor motivation: Diminished enthusiasm and drive for learning and exploration, impacting academic performance and overall development.
Procrastination: Delaying schoolwork and other responsibilities, fueled by a belief that success is unattainable regardless of effort.

Learned helplessness in children can also contribute to the development of anxiety, depression, or a combination of both. When children feel they have had no control over past events, they develop an expectation that future events will be similarly uncontrollable. This belief can lead to a sense of hopelessness and despair, increasing the risk of mental health challenges.

Academic struggles can be a significant trigger for learned helplessness in children. A child who consistently tries hard in school but continues to perform poorly may develop a belief that they have no control over their grades or academic performance. This can create a vicious cycle where they stop trying, leading to further academic difficulties and reinforcing their feelings of helplessness. These academic challenges can then spill over into other areas of the child’s life, impacting their self-esteem and motivation in various domains.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/GettyImages-1290940185-641931894b7e49598288f068.jpg)

Learned Helplessness and Mental Health: A Vicious Cycle

Learned helplessness is intricately linked to mental health, often contributing to feelings of anxiety and playing a significant role in the onset, severity, and persistence of conditions such as generalized anxiety disorder (GAD).

Individuals experiencing chronic anxiety may eventually develop learned helplessness regarding their condition. They may start to believe that their anxious feelings are unavoidable and untreatable, leading them to give up on seeking relief. This sense of futility can further exacerbate their anxiety and create a vicious cycle.

Similarly, in depression, learned helplessness reinforces feelings of hopelessness and lack of control, contributing to the depth and duration of depressive episodes. Individuals with depression may feel trapped in their negative emotions and believe that nothing can alleviate their suffering.

This sense of helplessness can also lead individuals experiencing mental health issues to resist seeking help. They may refuse medications or therapy, believing that these interventions will be ineffective. This avoidance of treatment further perpetuates their symptoms and reinforces their feelings of helplessness, creating a negative feedback loop.

As individuals age, learned helplessness can become an increasingly entrenched pattern. When faced with challenges such as anxiety or depression, they may default to a helpless mindset, believing that nothing can be done to improve their situation. This cycle of helplessness and inaction can significantly impair their quality of life and overall well-being.

Overcoming Learned Helplessness: Regaining Control

Fortunately, learned helplessness is not an irreversible condition. It can often be successfully reduced, particularly when intervention occurs in the early stages. Even long-term learned helplessness can be addressed with sustained effort and appropriate strategies. Effective strategies for overcoming learned helplessness include:

Psychotherapy: Cognitive Restructuring

Psychotherapy, particularly cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), is a highly effective approach for reducing symptoms of learned helplessness. CBT focuses on identifying and modifying negative thought patterns and behaviors that contribute to learned helplessness.

The core goal of CBT in this context is to help individuals recognize and challenge the negative and self-defeating thoughts that fuel their feelings of helplessness. This process involves:

Identifying negative thought patterns: Becoming aware of the automatic negative thoughts that arise in challenging situations, such as “I can’t do this,” or “It’s hopeless.”
Challenging negative thoughts: Questioning the validity and accuracy of these negative thoughts, examining the evidence for and against them.
Replacing negative thoughts with rational and optimistic thoughts: Developing more balanced and realistic perspectives, focusing on strengths, past successes, and potential for positive change.

This cognitive restructuring process empowers individuals to break free from the cycle of negative thinking and develop a more optimistic and proactive approach to challenges.

Self-Care Strategies: Fostering Agency

Engaging in self-care practices is crucial for building resilience and fostering a greater sense of control over one’s life, which is essential for overcoming learned helplessness.

Research suggests that physical exercise can be particularly beneficial in reducing symptoms of learned helplessness. Exercise has been shown to improve mood, reduce stress, and enhance feelings of self-efficacy and control.

Other important self-care strategies include:

Prioritizing sleep: Ensuring adequate and restful sleep, as sleep deprivation can exacerbate negative emotions and impair coping abilities.
Managing stress levels: Implementing stress-reduction techniques such as mindfulness, meditation, or yoga to mitigate the impact of stress on mental and emotional well-being.
Eating a healthy diet: Nourishing the body with a balanced and nutritious diet to support overall health and mental function.
Setting achievable goals: Breaking down large tasks into smaller, manageable steps to create a sense of progress and accomplishment.

By consistently practicing self-care, individuals can enhance their overall well-being and build a stronger foundation for resilience and control.

Social Support: Encouragement and Motivation

Seeking social support and encouragement from others plays a vital role in overcoming learned helplessness. When feeling helpless in the face of challenges, supportive friends, family members, or support groups can provide encouragement, motivation, and a sense of belonging.

Supportive individuals can help reframe negative thoughts, offer practical assistance, and remind individuals of their strengths and past successes. Social connection can combat feelings of isolation and hopelessness, fostering a sense of hope and agency.

With time, consistent effort, and the support of others, individuals can accumulate successful experiences that gradually replace feelings of helplessness with a renewed sense of control and optimism.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/GettyImages-1207288319-620e39c402b7492c8b491734.jpg)

A Word From Verywell: From Helplessness to Hope

Learned helplessness can have a profound and detrimental impact on mental health and overall well-being. Individuals experiencing learned helplessness are more likely to suffer from symptoms of depression, elevated stress levels, and reduced motivation to care for their physical health.

It is important to remember that not everyone responds to challenging experiences in the same way. Some individuals are more predisposed to learned helplessness due to a combination of biological and psychological factors. For example, children raised by parents who exhibit helpless behaviors are more likely to develop learned helplessness themselves, potentially through observational learning.

If you suspect that learned helplessness is negatively affecting your life, it is crucial to seek professional help. Talking to a doctor or mental health professional is the first step towards addressing this pattern of thinking.

A thorough evaluation can lead to an accurate understanding of your situation and the development of a personalized treatment plan. Therapy and other interventions can help you challenge negative thought patterns, build coping skills, and replace feelings of learned helplessness with a sense of learned optimism. By taking proactive steps, you can move from a state of helplessness to one of hope and empowerment, regaining control over your life and well-being.