Embarking on the journey of Mandarin Chinese Language Learning can be both exciting and daunting. Like many beginners, I once sought a magical shortcut to fluency, and language learning apps like Duolingo seemed to offer just that. A few summers ago, fueled by enthusiasm and a desire to speak Mandarin like a friend I’d met in China, I dove headfirst into Duolingo. Having dabbled in elementary Mandarin classes, I was eager for a convenient and engaging way to progress.
My friend, whose Mandarin skills I admired, recommended a free app for vocabulary and sentence structure building. Simultaneously, online searches for resources like “how long does it take to learn Chinese?” led me to claims that Duolingo users advanced as quickly as university students. Intrigued, I downloaded the app and was quickly drawn into its gamified approach.
Duolingo transforms language learning into an engaging game. Courses are structured by topics, starting with basic greetings and progressing to complex themes such as business and travel. Each course introduces topic-specific vocabulary and short sentences. To unlock subsequent courses and advance through the ‘tree’ of hundreds of lessons, users must complete challenges, such as sentence construction and translation exercises.
That summer, Duolingo consumed my spare time as I diligently worked to complete the entire Chinese tree. The app’s persuasive notifications, reminding me of my friend’s higher score, and the guilt-inducing emails from Duo, the owl mascot, whenever I skipped a lesson, were surprisingly effective motivators.
However, despite my dedication and completion of the Duolingo Chinese tree, fluency remained elusive. My spoken Mandarin was still at a basic elementary level, barely scratching the surface of the A1 level on the European framework.
Reflecting on this experience, particularly after a Spanish-learning friend shared an article defending Duolingo against criticism, I realized the app’s limitations for serious mandarin chinese language learning. While Duolingo has faced mockery for its often bizarre and nonsensical sentences, the app’s creators argue that these unusual sentences are intentionally designed to enhance memorability. Their article, “‘How silly sentences can help you learn’,” suggests sentences like “The Tuesday is similar to the Monday” act as “grammatical anchors,” aiding in the recall of grammar concepts and facilitating accurate communication. Communication, they assert, is about “learning rules and flexibility.”
I disagree with the notion that mastering Mandarin communication hinges primarily on rule memorization, and I strongly question the effectiveness of learning grammar through isolated, unnatural sentences that native speakers would never use. Memorability is irrelevant if the sentences are unnatural and do not reflect authentic language use. Effective mandarin chinese language learning should prioritize repeated exposure to and comprehension of thousands of sentences in natural contexts, ideally relevant to personal experiences. This immersive approach gradually makes grammatical structures feel intuitive and familiar.
Through years of studying effective mandarin chinese language learning methodologies employed by highly proficient speakers, I discovered that internalizing grammar patterns is best achieved through extensive consumption of comprehensible content. Techniques like sentence mining – collecting relevant phrases and structures – and consistent real-life application are far more impactful.
Alternative resources, such as graded readers, provide a superior immersion experience compared to Duolingo. Graded readers are specifically designed to enable learners with limited vocabulary to engage in extensive reading, unlike Duolingo’s fragmented, sentence-by-sentence approach. Compelling narratives and engaging articles in graded readers are far more effective and enjoyable than even the wackiest Duolingo sentences.
Shortly after my Duolingo phase, I discovered Mandarin Companion graded readers, which start at just 150 words vocabulary. Websites like LingQ also offer mini-stories tailored for beginners. Had I known about these resources earlier, I would have abandoned Duolingo sooner. Ultimately, it was these tools, combined with consistent speaking practice, not Duolingo, that propelled me towards fluency in Mandarin.
Duolingo does offer some value, particularly in the initial stages of mandarin chinese language learning, as a tool for vocabulary acquisition. It can introduce basic phrases, such as how to say hello in Mandarin. For learners with vocabularies below 150 words, Duolingo can bridge the gap to more meaningful content like graded readers and Mandarin novels.
However, even for vocabulary building, Duolingo is insufficient on its own. Reading Chinese effectively requires learning to read Chinese characters. Spaced Repetition Systems (SRS) flashcards are significantly more effective for character memorization and recall. While Duolingo includes some character introduction, it’s inadequate for long-term retention. Therefore, learners using Duolingo for vocabulary should supplement it with character flashcards or gamified SRS tools like Ninchanese.
Furthermore, while Duolingo touches upon Chinese tones, its tone training is insufficient for developing accurate pronunciation. Despite completing the Duolingo tree, my tone accuracy remained limited. I later had to dedicate significant effort to correcting my tones.
In retrospect, while my Duolingo experience wasn’t entirely negative, my obsession with it, fueled by the company’s misleading promise of fluency, was misguided. If I could restart my mandarin chinese language learning journey, I would use Duolingo briefly, alongside flashcards and other vocabulary tools, only until I could engage with meaningful texts. Then, I would move on to more effective and comprehensive methods.
Prioritize Clear Mandarin Communication?
If clear and confident Mandarin communication is your goal, focusing on tones from the outset is crucial. Subscribe to the Tones Mechanic, my free newsletter, and discover the step-by-step methods I used to refine my tones and achieve fluency in Mandarin.
Upon subscribing, you’ll also receive complimentary access to the Tones Masterclass video course, packed with detailed lessons and native audio examples. Begin your journey to tone mastery today!
Mischa Wilmers
Share this:
- Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
- Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
Like this:
Like Loading…
